Choosing the right tile flooring goes beyond appearance; it involves considering durability, quality, and long-term value. Not all tile brands are equal, and selecting the right one can save you time, money, and prevent costly repairs and replacements.
If you’re renovating your kitchen or bathroom, this guide provides insights into the most reliable tile flooring brands, based on industry standards and real-world performance. It also highlights brands to avoid. Whether you’re looking for premium porcelain, budget-friendly DIY options, or navigating big-box store brands, this analysis will help you make an informed decision.
Best overall tile brands of 2025
Armstrong Flooring is recognized as a leading tile brand in 2025, noted for consumer trust and sustainability. As highlighted by Lifestory Research 2025 America’s Most Trusted Study, Armstrong is known for its reliability and eco-friendly manufacturing. Its ADEX-winning sustainable flooring and low-VOC materials make it a top choice for quality and environmental responsibility. Armstrong offers a diverse range of styles for both residential and commercial buyers.
Mohawk Industries, through its Dal-Tile division, is praised for its durability, especially in high-traffic areas. Dal-Tile offers excellent wear resistance and is suitable for water-prone areas. They are easy to clean and resistant to denting. Porcelanosa, a premium brand, provides full-body porcelain tiles with ultra-low water absorption. Known for replicating natural stone and cement textures with detail, Porcelanosa integrates slip-resistant finishes for safety. Its combination of aesthetics and performance makes it ideal for upscale projects. Additionally, consumers can take steps to prevent scratches on porcelain tiles.
Brands to avoid and common issues
MSI, often available at Home Depot, faces significant quality control issues, making it a less reliable choice despite its accessibility. Customers frequently report problems like chipping and warping, which can be frustrating after installation. Installers also find these tiles prone to breaking during cutting. Additionally, MSI occasionally discontinues products, complicating replacements. However, this issue is not unique to MSI.
Floor & Decor’s proprietary tile brands, such as NuCore and Optimax, are marketed as affordable, but consumer experiences suggest otherwise. With numerous complaints filed with the Better Business Bureau, earning a “D-” rating, these tiles often face issues like buckling, peeling, and warping, frequently within a year of installation. Durability concerns arise in moisture-rich or temperature-fluctuating environments. Customers also face challenges in obtaining warranty coverage, resulting in costly repairs and replacements. Despite the initial low cost, the hidden expenses of ongoing repairs can exceed the cost of higher-quality options. Thus, it’s advisable to avoid these brands, especially if you need durable flooring for high-traffic areas like kitchens.
What consumers are saying
Consumers consistently commend Armstrong Flooring for its durability and wide range of designs. Many appreciate its resilience in high-traffic areas and the brand’s eco-friendly manufacturing. Although some have noted minor issues like yellowing over time, Armstrong remains a trusted choice for home and commercial use.
Mohawk Industries also receives positive reviews for its scratch-resistant surfaces and durable finishes. Customers highlight its capacity to withstand heavy use in busy households. However, some buyers face challenges with installing click-lock products and recommend professional installation for best results. For DIY enthusiasts, there are essential tips for perfect tile floor installation. Conversely, MSI and Floor & Decor’s NuCore and OptiMax lines often attract complaints. Common issues include inconsistent tile sizing, early cracking, and poor warranty service. Many homeowners report buckling or warping within a year, making them a riskier choice despite the lower cost.
